In Defense of Torture.

Ragusa · Sep 7, 2008

Remove all ads!
I have found a memo that echoes some of the sadly familiar arguments that could be heard being made on torture in the last years. I'll let it and the author speak for themselves.

To the Secretaries of oblast and regional party committees,
To the CCs of national Communist parties,
To the people's commissars of internal affairs,
and to the heads of NKVD directorates

It has become known to the VKP CC that the secretaries of oblast and regional party committees, in checking up on employees of NKVD directorates, have laid blame on them for the use of physical pressure against those who have been arrested, treating it as something criminal. The VKP CC affirms that the use of physical pressure in the work of the NKVD has been permitted since 1937 in accordance with a resolution of the VKP CC. This directive indicated that physical pressure was to be used in exceptional cases and only against blatant enemies of the people who, when interrogated by humane methods, defiantly refuse to turn over the names of co-conspirators, and who refuse for months on end to provide any evidence, and who try to thwart the unmasking of co-conspirators who are still at large, and who thereby continue even from prison to wage a struggle against the Soviet regime.

Experience has shown that such an arrangement has produced good results and has greatly expedited the unmasking of enemies of the people. True, subsequently in practice the method of physical pressure was abused by Zakovsky, Litvin, Uspensky, and other scoundrels, converting it from an exception into a rule and beginning to apply it against honest people who had been arrested accidentally. For these abuses, they [the scoundrels] have been given due punishment. But this in no way detracts from the value of the method itself when it is properly used. It is known that all bourgeois secret services use physical pressure against representatives of the socialist proletariat and rely on especially savage methods of it. We might therefore ask why a socialist secret service should be any more more humane in relation to inveterate agent of the bourgeoisie and sworn enemies of the working class and collectivized farmers.

The VKP CC believes that the use of physical pressure must absolutely be continued from here on in exceptional cases and against blatant and invidious enemies of the people, and that this is a perfectly appropriate and desirable method. The VKP CC demands that the secretaries of oblast and regional party committees and the CCs of national party committees bear in mind this explanation when they check up on the employees of NKVD directorates.

Secretary of the VKP CC
J. Stalin
10.1.1939
Click to expand...

To sum it up:

Torture is only applied in exceptional circumstances, that is, it's just the worst of the worst who get tortured.

Torture produces good results. It works.

The dire circumstances justify torture - there is a clear and present external threat.

Torture is justified because it is the only timely way to get to the information.

Without torture the enemy would persistently resist.

The enemy is, if anything, worse.

Excesses are lamentable but to be accepted.

One point that has to be said in favour of Stalin, when he wrote that those scoundrels who excessed had been duly punished, he meant it. One much more interesting thing is that even Stalin, presumably the absolute ruler over everything Soviet, had to write this memo in defence of torture.

Thoughts? Rant away.

Log in or Sign up

In Defense of Torture.

Ragusa Eternal Halfling Paladin Veteran